8 Best Ways to Invest a Lump Sum Life Insurance Payout [2023]

When someone close to us dies, one of the many things we have to deal with is dealing with their life insurance policy. Often, this means receiving a lump sum payout which can be a lot to handle emotionally and financially. It’s important to remember that this money is meant to help you in your time of need and should not be squandered.

That means first covering your pressing needs like funeral expenses, but also paying bills, shedding high cost debt and putting food on the table. From that point, it means looking into how to invest life insurance proceeds for long-term financial security.

Here are some tips on how to invest life insurance proceeds wisely for both short-term and long-term needs.

What to Do With Life Insurance Money – Best Investment Picks

What is Best to Do With Life Insurance Payout Proceeds?

Examining documents together

After receiving a life insurance payout, your top priority should be to ensure you are financially secure for the near future. If possible, that means becoming debt free.

Set aside enough to cover your living expenses, other necessities, and create a fully-funded emergency fund.

Once you’ve established financial security, make the remaining money grow and work for you by investing it wisely.

Life insurance policies don’t provide unlimited money, so you need to use the money they provide strategically.

Consider the following short-term needs before investing anything for the long-term.

1. Pay off outstanding debts

Pay off any high-interest debt you have, such as credit card debt. Eliminating your high-interest debt will save you money in the long run and prevent a significant amount of stress.

You don’t need to rush to pay off low-interest debt, like a mortgage. Mortgages and low-interest student loans are considered “good debt” while credit card debt and other personal loans are considered bad debt.

Even if you do well investing, bad debt can accumulate quicker than your investment gains. Low-interest debt can be paid off slower while you keep enough of your money liquid.

2. Cover living expenses (keep money to pay bills)

Make a list of all of your living expenses, including rent, utilities, phone plans, internet, food, gas, and more.

You need enough money to keep the lights on, so calculate how much money that takes and give yourself a bit of a buffer.

Look through old bank or credit card statements to remind yourself of any expenses you may be forgetting that occur less regularly but can dramatically impact your finances.

Set money aside for these expenses before spending any of it.

3. Build an emergency fund in an interest-bearing account

Depending on your financial situation and life circumstances, you’ll want to keep 3-6 (or more) months of living expenses in a savings account.

Sometimes, tragic events come in pairs or threes and you never know when you might need an unexpected car repair, have your hours reduced at work, or you develop a health issue.

Keep your emergency fund in an interest-bearing account (think high-yield savings account over checking account) so it can grow as it sits providing you peace of mind (and hopefully isn’t touched).

4. Spend on necessities

Don’t feel guilty spending death benefit funds on necessities, such as a roof or vehicle repair. If your shoes are falling apart, go ahead and buy a new pair.

Just don’t spend the life insurance money on luxuries, like a fancy watch, if you want it to last.

Money spent on a whim can deplete quickly, especially if you aren’t currently working and bringing in more of it.

5. Whatever’s left, consider investing

Once you’ve made ends meet and you’ve established a solid financial footing, consider investing the rest of the money so that it can increase your net worth and provide you a source of income for longer.

While we walk through the various options to invest money left to you through a life insurance death benefit, feel free to consult financial professionals like a financial planner.

We recommend a fee only financial planner if you’d prefer to go this route, because they get paid for their services, not by commission or how much you invest with them.

How to Invest Your Life Insurance Benefit

Invest for Income

1. Bonds

Human Hand Showing Unbalance Between Rolled Up dollars On Seesaw

Borrowers, such as companies or the government, issue bonds to raise money and fund their operations. The bond works as a loan from investors.

Investors make money from bonds in two ways:

  1. holding them until the maturity date and collecting interest payments
  2. selling them at a higher price to someone else before maturity (in addition to collecting interest payments along the way).

Companies send interest payments on bonds at regular intervals in predictable amounts if they have fixed rates.

While you want your life insurance proceeds to grow for your longer-term needs, holding bonds serves as a solid addition to investment portfolios for the income they provide.

Related: Best Stock Portfolio Tracking Apps

2. Dividend Stocks

counting money Despite being associated with lower long-term returns than many other asset classes, dividend stocks still serve as a compelling option in some cases.

Dividends are regular cash payments issued to shareholders. When thinking of high-yield investments, these likely represent the most direct way to consider how an investment can put money back in your possession.

Because of this direct cash transfer, dividends also tell a lot about the risk profile of a stock.

When thinking about the risks involved with a stock that pays dividends (or not), consider some of these factors:

  1. The dividend should be far more consistent and declared in a similar (or growing amount) each quarter. Whether the stock goes up or down, the dividend comes to your brokerage account just the same. Even if your stock underperforms for a while, these dividends should give you something of value and make it easier to hold onto the stock during a market swoon or period of underperformance.
  2. Dividends tend to buffer significant falls in price, assuming economic circumstances don’t warrant cutting dividends. Also, dividend payments remain fixed in dollars per share terms, but dividend yields can rise when a stock’s price falls. That measure represents the amount of money you can expect to return based on the company’s current share price in a year. As a stock’s price falls, you’re paying less for that same dividend—assuming the company doesn’t cut it.
  3. Dividends represent stability to investors. Each period, the company needs to have a certain amount of cash go out the door to investors. This minimum level of cash flow going off the balance sheet means companies need to be less risky and plan for this ongoing cost as part of their corporate strategy.
Read more  Gas Trading - How to Invest in Natural Gas

As mentioned above, companies can—and some will—slash their dividends in times of economic uncertainty. While usually one of the last items for a company to cut, because it usually results in the stock plunging—people buy dividend stocks for their consistency.

When the company threatens that consistency, investors tend to sell in favor of other investment options.

Look for companies with a consistent history of dividend growth and high yields. Further, you want to monitor payout and debt to equity ratios.

Payout ratios represent the amount of dividends paid out in relation to a company’s net income.

As companies payout more of their net income in dividends, this represents a higher dividend payout ratio, but also a greater risk the company can’t continue reinvesting in its business.

When a company pays out 50% or less of their net income in dividends, this usually represents a safer dividend investment. Above this, it shows too much of the company’s earnings go toward paying a dividend to investors.

Debt-to-equity ratios show how much debt a company uses to fund its operations and ongoing investments. Lower debt-to-equity ratios represent lower risk companies, all things equal.

If a company fails to grow their income, the debt costs can eat an increasing share of their cash flow, limiting a company’s ability to grow or even survive.

Conservative investors tend to find more comfort in dividend stocks with good dividend growth, yields, payout ratios and debt-to-income scores because they have less risk tolerance and still get rewarded for their investment choices through regular dividend payments.

Related: How to Research Stocks Before You Buy [How to Pick Stocks]

3. Real Estate

commercial real estate REIT apartment tenants

Real estate can be an excellent way to create a passive income. Some people choose to buy properties to rent out to tenants.

If you can afford to purchase and manage short-term or long-term rentals, it can be very profitable.

However, there are ways to receive money from real estate without such a substantial upfront cost and hassle as well.

You could invest in online real estate investments with companies such as Fundrise for non-accredited investors or YieldStreet for accredited investors.

These platforms allow you to invest in pieces of properties like apartments, commercial real estate, multi-family housing, and more that you couldn’t afford on your own. You receive money from dividends, property sales, or both.

An even simpler way to make money from real estate is by purchasing real estate investment trusts (REITs).

A REIT is a company that pools investors’ money to buy and manage real estate properties. Usually, these are commercial or high-end properties.

You can buy REITs in standard brokerage accounts or through private offerings like Streitwise.

Investors receive dividends for as long as they hold their REITs and can sell a REIT at any time, possibly even for more than they originally paid.

Another option is to buy real estate exchange-traded funds (ETFs). These funds invest the majority of their assets in equity REIT securities and are passively managed.

Just like with REITs, you receive dividends while you hold the ETF and can sell whenever you want, typically for more money.

Note that for both types of investments, your dividends carry a variety of tax treatments, depending on the nature of the dividends paid.

REIT dividends can constitute three tax treatments:

  1. A tax-free return of capital
  2. ordinary income
  3. capital gain

Make sure you understand the tax implications of the passive income tax rates and rules that apply to REITs.

4. Alternative Investments

Macro view of rows of gold bars

Sometimes, more “alternative” investments can have higher gains than standard investments.

Don’t make your entire investment portfolio consist of alternative investments, but owning some might help you if the stock market takes a downturn.

One of the first investments that may have come to your mind when you hear “alternative investments” might be cryptocurrency.

However, at this point, crypto’s gone mainstream enough that it may not feel very alternative anymore. Even non-fungible tokens, called NFTs, have cracked the regular headlines we see.

Nearly 70 million people around the world use blockchain wallets. Today, it’s possible to trade cryptocurrencies on apps like Robinhood.

Another alternative investment growing in popularity is fine wine. According to the investment consultancy Knight Frank’s 2021 Wealth Report, fine wine appreciated 127% over the last decade.

Wine isn’t strongly correlated with the stock market and can be up even during a recession. Vint and Vinovest are two popular wine investing platforms.

Blue-chip art, peer-to-peer lending, and mineral rights are just a few other alternative investments to consider.

Related: 11 Best Non-Stock Investments [Alternatives to the Stock Market]

5. Consider an Annuity

evaluating a portfolio weighting

Annuities provide a guaranteed income stream, so you never have to worry about completely running out of money.

You can purchase annuities from an insurance company, bank, independent broker, or other established, reputable financial groups.

There are a variety of annuities to choose among. Some are bought by paying a lump sum, which you could easily do after receiving a death benefit. Others can be purchased through making a series of payments.

You have to decide if you want a fixed annuity with a consistent interest rate or a variable annuity where the return depends on the performance of the underlying investments.

Variable annuities have higher growth potential, but also carry more risk because you may not receive as much money.

Discuss annuity options with an insurance company, certified financial planner or other qualified financial professional to decide which type of annuity might be best for you.

While these can generate income and guaranteed payments, make sure to incorporate these as part of a broader financial planning effort and not as your entire investment strategy.

In some cases, you might consider a purchasing a permanent life insurance policy for its financial flexibility and ability to build a tax-advantaged cash value over time.

Related: Best Income-Generating Assets [Invest in Cash Flow]

Invest for Growth

young woman office building call

Investing for growth means you buy investments that focus on capital appreciation.

You don’t receive money until you sell the investment, but if you hold it long enough, you have the potential to make much more money than you spent.

If you were issued a lump sum payment from an insurance company, this might be a wise option for you.

You can store your growth investments in taxable brokerage accounts and tax-advantaged accounts to build long-term wealth. Each type of account has its own set of advantages.

Retirement accounts are either tax-deferred, meaning you don’t have to pay taxes until later, or funded with post-tax money that grows tax-free.

These tax benefits can save you a significant amount of money.

Read more  Audiobooks for Real Estate Investors

Taxable brokerage accounts, unlike retirement accounts, have no contribution limits. You can invest as much money as you want.

Additionally, money in taxable brokerage accounts is liquid. You can sell stocks, index funds, and other liquid investments at any time.

When you withdraw cash from the sales, you don’t pay any early withdrawal penalties.

Consider putting portions of your life insurance death benefit in both types of accounts to build long-term wealth. Below, read about three of the best growth investments to hold.

Related: Best Commission-Free Stock Trading Apps & Platforms

6. Growth Stocks

investment stockbroker stock market analysis data graph on smartphone

Investing is a way of setting aside money that will work for you so in the future, you can reap all the benefits from your hard work.

Perhaps said best by legendary investor Warren Buffett, investing is “…the process of laying out money now to receive more money in the future.”

Investing aims to put your money to work and grow it over time. Growth stocks take this to another level by seeking capital appreciation as their main investing goal.

Growth stocks belong to growth-oriented businesses, including industries such as technology, healthcare and consumer goods.

Growth companies traditionally work well for investors focused on the future potential of companies.

Growth companies focus on reinvestment and continuous innovation, which typically leads them to pay little to no dividends to stockholders, opting instead to put most or all its profits back into expanding its business.

Some popular growth companies include firms like Google, Apple and Tesla.

Despite constantly reinvesting in the business, growth stocks are not without risk. Companies can make poor decisions, markets overvalue stocks, and economic mishaps can derail companies with even the best prospects.

However, growth stocks as a whole tend to provide the best return on investment over time if you can tolerate the volatility that comes with them.

But, take risks cautiously. While growth companies have a higher probability of providing an excellent return when compared to other types of investments, you should balance how much risk you are willing to tolerate.

Some companies grow at breakneck speed but have valuations to match. Taking on too much risk can undermine a portfolio and tank returns.

You might consider using an award-winning service like Motley Fool’s Rule Breakers to find high-growth stocks that have potential to outperform the market.

Take a look below at the details of this service and whether it might make a good addition to your investor toolkit.

Motley Fool Rule Breakers: Best for Long-Term Investors Looking for Growth Stocks

motley fool rule breakers sign up

  • Available: Sign up here
  • Best for: Buy-and-hold growth investors
  • Price: Discounted rate for the first year

Motley Fool Rule Breakers focuses on stocks that have massive growth potential in emerging industries. This service isn’t fixating on what’s currently popular, but rather always looking for the next big stock.

The service has six rules they follow before making stock recommendations to subscribers:

  1. Only invest in “top dog” companies in an emerging industry – As Motley Fool puts it: “It doesn’t matter if you’re the big player in floppy drives — the industry is falling apart.”
  2. The company must have a sustainable advantage
  3. Company must have strong past price appreciation
  4. Company needs to have strong and competent management
  5. There must be strong consumer appeal
  6. Financial media must overvalue the company

As you can see, before recommending a stock to users, Rule Breakers considers a number of factors. In short, the service mainly looks for well-run companies in emerging industries with a sustainable advantage over competitors, among other factors.

And their rules seem to pay off if their results have anything to say about it.

Over the past 19 years, Rule Breakers has more than doubled the S&P 500, beating many leading money managers on Wall Street through October 3, 2023. Their results speak for themselves and easily justify the affordable price tag for the first year.

rb vs sp500 oct 3 2023

What to Expect from Motley Fool’s Rule Breakers:

The service includes three primary items you can expect to receive:

  1. A listing of Starter Stocks to begin your Rule Breakers journey with their “essential Rule Breakers”
  2. 5 “Best Buys Now” opportunities each month
  3. Two new stock picks each month

You’ll receive regular communications from the stock picking service with their analysis and rationales for buying stocks meeting their investment criteria.

If you’re unhappy with the service within the first month, you can receive a full refund.

Read more in our Motley Fool Rule Breakers review.

Related: 13 Best Stock & Investment Newsletters for Inbox Alpha

7. Steady Eddies (Blue Chips)

young woman thinking coffee enjoying life

“Steady Eddy” investing focuses on blue chip companies with consistent results and long-term growth.

They offer dependable, high-conviction investment opportunities you can rely on to hold steady even when the going gets tough.

These companies tend to perform well on account of having a strong economic moat, or competitive advantage, they’ve built for themselves in a mature business.

They can build a moat in many ways, such as offering unique products and services, owning a patent or novel technology, having a significant first-mover advantage in a market, or another compelling reason why this company will likely be around for years to come.

Steady Eddies also tend to be the largest companies, and thus not have high growth prospects. However, they often can do well in any economic environment.

To the point, these companies offer resiliency during market uncertainty and can rely on incredibly stable and recurring sources of revenues—offering investors a higher chance for realizing long records of positive returns and an investment that can stand the test of time.

If you’d like help with finding high-quality companies that provide steady returns over time, you might consider another service from Motley Fool called Stock Advisor.

Below, we talk more about the service, including the types of companies the stock picking service recommends and the returns they’ve achieved to date.

Motley Fool Stock Advisor – Best for Buy and Hold Investors

motley fool stock advisor signup no price

  • Available: Sign up here
  • Best for: Buy-and-hold growth investors
  • Price: Discounted rate for the first year

The main difference between Motley Fool’s services is the type of stock pick recommendations.

Stock Advisor primarily recommends well-established companies. Over a decade ago, they advised subscribers to buy companies such as Netflix and Disney, which have been majorly successful.

As a subscriber, you’re granted access to their history of recommendations and can see for yourself how they have done over the years.

According to their website, the Motley Fool Stock Advisor stock subscription service has returned of 468% since their inception in February 2002 through October 3, 2023 when you calculate the average return of all their stock recommendations over the last 21 years.

Comparatively, the S&P 500 only had a 124% return during that same timeframe.

sa vs sp500 oct 3 2023

What to Expect from Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor:

The Stock Advisor service provides a lot of worthwhile resources to subscribers.

  1. “Starter Stocks” recommendations to serve as a foundation to your portfolio for new and experienced investors
  2. Two new stock picks each month
  3. 10 “Best Buys Now” chosen from over 300 stocks the service watches
  4. Investing resources with the stock picking service’s library of stock recommendations
  5. Access to community of investors engaged in outperforming the market and talking shop
Read more  How to Invest in Kenya for American Citizens

The service has a discounted rate for the first year and has a 30-day membership refund period. Consider signing up for Stock Advisor today.

Read more in our Motley Fool Stock Advisor review.

Related: Best Stock Market Investing Research & Analysis Websites

8. Index Funds

Index funds follow a benchmark index, such as the S&P 500. Index funds are considered low risk because they are highly diversified.

You can usually get an S&P 500 index fund or another index for a low price and minimal fees. The expense ratio is low because the funds are passively managed.

You’re also saving money because index funds tend to be tax-efficient. Since index funds have a low turnover ratio, meaning account managers don’t buy in and out of investments often, they have greater tax-efficiency than actively managed funds.

The low turnover also means there aren’t often capital gains taxes for shareholders to pay.

Perhaps most importantly, index funds typically have high returns that beat most actively managed mutual funds. When choosing an index fund to invest in, make sure to compare expense ratios.

Related: Best Stock Trading Apps for Beginners

Related Questions on How to Invest Life Insurance Proceeds

Do Beneficiaries Pay Taxes on Life Insurance Proceeds?

Typically, beneficiaries don’t have to pay taxes against the life insurance proceeds, or the death benefit, they receive.

Life insurance proceeds aren’t usually taxable, but any interest received is considered taxable income. However, there are a few exceptions.

If the insured individual holds a life insurance policy that pays cash dividends, the dividends don’t count as income on the taxpayer’s return.

Provided the amount received doesn’t exceed the net premiums paid on the policy, this passive income gets favorable tax treatment.

One of the exceptions occurs when life insurance ownership is transferred to another person for cash or other valuable consideration.

Meaning, if you buy or sell the life insurance contract, like any other time a sale occurs, taxes sneak in. They can apply under something the IRS calls the transfer-for-value rule.

When this happens, you can exclude the price you paid and any additional premiums you pay after the purchase.

For example, suppose you bought a $500,000 life insurance policy for $120,000. You paid $100,000 in premiums before the insured passed away and the death benefit was paid out.

You could then exclude the costs you already paid, meaning $120,000 + $100,000 = $220,000, from your income.

To make everything a bit trickier, this exception has exceptions of its own. The IRS Publication 525 has more details you can review to see if your life insurance death benefit situation would be taxed.

How Do You Live Off a Life Insurance Payout?

Even a high death benefit from a life insurance company can disappear quickly if you don’t manage the funds appropriately.

If you want to live off a death benefit, start by paying off high-interest debt because that will save you money long-term.

Once you have enough money set aside for bills, necessities, and a fully-funded emergency fund, invest the money so it can grow rather than keep depleting.

You might choose to focus on investing for income so you continuously receive dividend payments.

Alternatively, you could also invest for growth and buy assets known to grow in value. Later, you can sell these investments for a profit when you need more money.

Many people choose to do a combination of both. Basically, if you want to live off a death benefit, you need to make your money grow and work for you.

Related: How to Make Money in Stocks [Investing in the Stock Market]

Can You Put Life Insurance Proceeds Into an IRA?

Once life insurance companies pay a death benefit, the recipient can do anything they want with the money.

You can’t directly roll over the life insurance proceeds, however, you can use what you cash out.

But, remember, this money is usually tax-free and not earned income and you can’t contribute more to an individual retirement account (IRA) than you made each year.

Let’s say you and your partner were full-time workers. Money was tight, so you hadn’t maxed out your retirement accounts yet that year and you and your partner had top-notch life insurance policies.

After your partner passed away, you received a sizeable lump sum death benefit.

You could certainly use some of that money to max out an IRA as long as the amount doesn’t exceed the income you made that year.

The life insurance payout doesn’t constitute earned income, the only type of money you can place inside an IRA.

If you and your partner were married and filed jointly, you could contribute even if you didn’t work that year as long as the joint return showed enough earned income.

However, if you were unmarried and not working, the life insurance benefit isn’t earned income you could contribute.

Related: Best Investments for Roth IRA Accounts [Target High-Growth]

Is It Better to Take the Lump Sum Death Benefit for Life Insurance?

The vast majority of people choose to take the lump sum payout. Those who don’t can instead opt for a retained asset account.

Receiving a lump sum from the life insurance company allows you to quickly pay off any debt before more interest accumulates.

It also gives the life insurance beneficiary the possibility to invest the money that isn’t needed right away so it can grow.

Some people don’t trust themselves with substantial amounts of money from life insurance payouts while grieving. Others don’t trust themselves with significant amounts of money, period.

Anyone who eases pain with “retail therapy” might fare better having the death benefit paid out in a retained asset account.

Retained asset accounts are controlled by a life insurance company and work like checking accounts.

The life insurance death benefit in the account earns a low interest rate and you can withdraw money with the provided checkbook.

As long as you are careful with your money, the lump sum payout is the better option.

How Do I File a Claim With the Life Insurance Company for Life Insurance Proceeds?

You can’t receive your life insurance death benefits until you file a life insurance claim. Contact your agent or the life insurance company directly.

Many people keep life insurance policies in a home safe. If you can’t remember the name of the insurance company and can’t find the policy, check your bank statements.

When you contact the insurance agent, have them pull up your life insurance policy to verify you are listed as a beneficiary.

The insurance company can tell you where to find the claim form. You will need to fill out that form and send them a certified copy of the death certificate.

Be prepared to answer whether you want the money as a lump sum or kept in a retained asset account.

As long as there aren’t signs of fraud or other issues (for example, a term life insurance policy doesn’t cover death from self-inflicted wounds), you should receive payment from the life insurance coverage in a few days or weeks.

Related: Best Brokerage Account Sign-Up Bonuses, Promotions and Deals